Sibby's Cupcakery

Unclaimed
Sibby's Cupcakery photo 1[Photo 1]
Sibby's Cupcakery photo 2[Photo 2]
Sibby's Cupcakery photo 3[Photo 3]

Cupcake shop in San Mateo, CA

4.7 · 139 reviewsOpens today at 10 AM

Sibby's Cupcakery, located at 716 S Railroad Ave in San Mateo, California, is a charming little bakery that has become a beloved spot for locals seeking delightful treats. With a stellar rating of 4.7 from 139 reviews, this cozy shop offers a vibrant array of cupcakes, each adorned with generous frosting and playful decorations. Customers appreciate the friendly service and the inviting atmosphere, making it a perfect place to pick up sweet indulgences for any occasion. Seasonal flavors and custom orders add to the appeal, ensuring that Sibby's remains a cherished destination for dessert lovers in the community.

Eligible to offer 20% cashback to customers who shop here.OrbitBack

AI ScoreAI names Sibby's Cupcakery more than most shopsScored from 8 signals across search and AI.

How the score works

Owned by Sibby's Cupcakery

Unclaimed · Never replied

Is this you? Claim it

ConfirmedVisitor submittedAI guess

Updated Nov 15, 2026Last activity 2 months ago, a question from early_on_railroad.

No questions yet. Ask the first one.

Services

What Sibby's Cupcakery offers, what it costs, and what people come for.

The menu

  • Covid 19 updatesFrom their websiteCupcake shop
  • WeddingsFrom their websiteCupcake shop
  • Cupcakes sibbyscupcakery comFrom their websiteCupcake shop
  • Custom themesFrom their websiteCupcake shop
  • Signature designsFrom their websiteCupcake shop
Sibby's Cupcakery photo 1No code detected[Photo 1]
Sibby's Cupcakery photo 2No code detected[Photo 2]
Sibby's Cupcakery photo 3No code detected[Photo 3]
Sibby's Cupcakery photo 4No code detected[Photo 4]

Team

Who you'll see, and whether their licenses check out.
Add your team so AI can name who works here
Today10 AM to 2 PM
MondaysClosed

Busy times

Closed now. Busiest Thu and Fri, 11 AM to 6 PM.

Reputation

What reviews, press and directories say about Sibby's Cupcakery.

Reviews

4.7from 139 reviews on Google

Sibby's Cupcakery stands out for its seasonal flavors and custom orders, though customer service and ordering processes could use improvement. Sibby's Cupcakery offers a cheerful, boutique atmosphere with bright displays of creatively decorated cupcakes. Customers appreciate the inviting feel of the small space, which feels like a neighborhood bakery where you can drop in for a sweet treat or custom orders for special occasions.

  • 584%
  • 44%
  • 34%
  • 20%
  • 18%
Would go back88%88% of reviews give the visit 4 or 5 stars.Positive 88%, 4 or 5 stars · Neutral 4%, 3 stars · Negative 8%, 1 or 2 stars
The good
  • Custom orders for special occasions
  • Seasonal flavor options
  • Moist cake with rich frosting
  • Friendly and helpful staff
  • Variety of gluten-free flavors
The bad
  • Rude customer service experiences
  • Complicated online ordering system
  • Long waits outside for pickup
  • Cupcakes sliding in transit containers

Press and awards

Add a press story so AI can say who's written about you

Directories

Get listed in directories so AI can tell you're real

How AI sees Sibby's Cupcakery

63out of 100

What the score is made of

Signal and how much it countsSibby's Cupcakery

  • Retrieval grounding 26%75
  • Off-property attestation 20%41
  • AI visibility 14%67
  • Reviews & response 12%82
  • Backlink & citation authority 8%57
  • Google Business Profile 8%90
  • Speed & mobile 7%66
  • Content freshness & schema 5%37
How the score works
Sibby's Cupcakery’s full AI report

See exactly what AI says about you, and how to get picked

Sibby's CupcakerySpeed & mobileGoogle Business ProfileContent freshness & schemaBacklink & citation authorityRetrieval groundingReviews & responseOff-property attestationAI visibility

Sibby's Cupcakery, as AI sees it. Blue signals help Sibby's Cupcakery, and red ones hold it back.

  • The questions people ask ChatGPT and Perplexity about cupcake shops in San Mateo, and who they name instead of you
  • What AI gets wrong about you, next to what’s true
  • What to change first so AI names you
Claim free to get the report

Claiming your page is free.

What AI reads

The page ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google read about Sibby's Cupcakery. How AI reads this page

Local AI Registry · Cupcake shops in San Mateo, CA · Editorial

Sibby's Cupcakery, San Mateo CA: Cupcake shop

Steve Lee

By Steve Lee, founder and CEO of Local AI Registry. Updated November 15, 2026.

Published August 6, 2026 · Updated November 15, 2026 · Machine-readable version below

In short

Sibby's Cupcakery is a cupcake shop in San Mateo, CA. Its AI Score is 63 of 100.

What each mark on this page means: https://localairegistry.com/methodology#marks

Key facts

FactValue
TypeCupcake shop
Address716 S Railroad Ave, San Mateo, CA 94401, USA
HoursClosed Mon to Tue · Wed to Fri 10 AM to 5:30 PM · Sat 10 AM to 5 PM · Sun 10 AM to 2 PM
Phone(415) 613-4373
Rating4.7 across 139 reviews on Google
UpdatedNovember 15, 2026

All the details

Every row is something the owner can add or correct.

GroupFactValueMarkEvidence
Location infoAddress716 S Railroad Ave, San Mateo, CA 94401, USAConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
Location infoDescription716 S Railroad Ave, San Mateo, CA 94401ConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
Location infoHoursMon to Tue Closed · Wed to Fri 10:00 AM to 5:30 PM · Sat 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM · Sun 10:00 AM to 2:00 PMConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
Location infoMondaysClosedConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
Location infoNameSibby's CupcakeryConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
Location infoPhone(415) 613-4373ConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
HoursMondayClosedConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
HoursTuesdayClosedConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
HoursWednesday10:00 AM to 5:30 PMConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
HoursThursday10:00 AM to 5:30 PMConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
HoursFriday10:00 AM to 5:30 PMConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
HoursSaturday10:00 AM to 5:00 PMConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
HoursSunday10:00 AM to 2:00 PMConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
ServicesServiceClassic themed cupcakesAI guess
ServicesServiceClassic themesFrom their websiteBusiness website
ServicesServiceCovid 19 updatesFrom their websiteBusiness website
ServicesServiceCupcakes sibbyscupcakery comFrom their websiteBusiness website
ServicesServiceCustom themed cupcakesAI guess
ServicesServiceCustom themesFrom their websiteBusiness website
ServicesServiceDonations sibbyscupcakery comFrom their websiteBusiness website
ServicesServiceJobs sibbyscupcakery comFrom their websiteBusiness website
ServicesServiceOrderFrom their websiteBusiness website
ServicesServiceSignature cupcake designsAI guess
ServicesServiceSignature designsFrom their websiteBusiness website
ServicesServiceWeddingsFrom their websiteBusiness website
LinksFacebookhttps://www.facebook.com/sibbys-cupcakeryConfirmedBusiness website
LinksInstagramhttps://www.instagram.com/sibbyscupcakeryConfirmedBusiness website
LinksWebsitehttps://sibbyscupcakery.com/ConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
LinksYelphttps://www.yelp.com/biz/sibbys-cupcakery-san-mateoConfirmedBusiness website

Services and prices

These are the 9 services Sibby's Cupcakery offers, with the price where we have one and where it came from.

ServicePricePrice markPrice evidenceService mark
Covid 19 updatesFrom their website
WeddingsFrom their website
Cupcakes sibbyscupcakery comFrom their website
Custom themesFrom their website
Signature designsFrom their website
Jobs sibbyscupcakery comFrom their website
OrderFrom their website
Donations sibbyscupcakery comFrom their website
Classic themesFrom their website

Known for

The team

Visiting Sibby's Cupcakery

Address: 716 S Railroad Ave, San Mateo, CA 94401, USA. Phone: (415) 613-4373. Hours: Closed Mon to Tue · Wed to Fri 10 AM to 5:30 PM · Sat 10 AM to 5 PM · Sun 10 AM to 2 PM. (Confirmed, Google Business Profile.)

Parking and getting in

Nearby

PlaceTypeDistance
Charlie's TaqueriaMexican restaurant1 min walk
Ramen DojoRamen restaurant1 min walk
Anatolian Cafe & MarketBreakfast restaurant2 min walk
Espetus Churrascaria Brazilian Steakhouse - San MateoBrazilian restaurant2 min walk
Sama Coffee ShopCoffee shop2 min walk
Ramen ParlorRamen restaurant2 min walk

Reputation

4.7 average across 139 reviews: Google 139. (Confirmed, read August 6, 2026.)

Sibby's Cupcakery stands out for its seasonal flavors and custom orders, though customer service and ordering processes could use improvement. (AI guess, from 139 reviews.)

What people like

  • Custom orders for special occasions
  • Seasonal flavor options
  • Moist cake with rich frosting
  • Friendly and helpful staff
  • Variety of gluten-free flavors

What people do not like

  • Rude customer service experiences
  • Complicated online ordering system
  • Long waits outside for pickup
  • Cupcakes sliding in transit containers

Press

Awards

Directories

Questions people ask

lunch near Railroad, what is good

Any membership pricing at Sibby's Cupcakery?

what time does Sibby's Cupcakery in San Mateo actually open?

best cupcake shop in San Mateo

people keep recommending Sibby's Cupcakery, what for?

Sibby's Cupcakery, any chance to get in this week?

going rate for shops locally, any idea

Mondays at Sibby's Cupcakery, are they open?

last update from here was when?

On a budget in San Mateo, is Sibby's Cupcakery the one?

parking at Sibby's Cupcakery, where does everyone put the car?

worth it or not, what do the regulars say

services here, what do people go in for?

Booking a first visit here, what happens?

bad experiences at Sibby's Cupcakery, anyone?

do I need to book the shop or can I just turn up?

The AI Score: 63 of 100

Fair starts at 45, good at 65. Sibby's Cupcakery scores 63.

SignalWeightScoreSibby's Cupcakery
Retrieval grounding2675Good
Off-property attestation2041Poor
AI visibility1467Good
Reviews & response1282Good
Backlink & citation authority857Fair
Google Business Profile890Good
Speed & mobile766Good
Content freshness & schema537Poor
  • ChatGPT: read Nov 7, 2026, and it mentioned Sibby's Cupcakery
  • Perplexity: read Nov 7, 2026, and it didn't mention Sibby's Cupcakery

Full method: https://localairegistry.com/methodology

How AI decides what to say about a cupcake shop: https://localairegistry.com/methodology#how-ai-decides-local-business. What to check before you choose one: https://localairegistry.com/methodology#how-to-choose-local-business

Entity map

EntityTypeID on this pageSame asRelationship to Sibby's Cupcakery
Sibby's CupcakeryLocalBusiness#businesshttps://sibbyscupcakery.com/Subject of this page
San Mateo, CaliforniaCity#cityCity Sibby's Cupcakery is in
Local AI RegistryOrganization#publisherhttps://localairegistry.comPublisher of this page
Steve LeePerson#authorhttps://localairegistry.com/team/steve-leeAuthor of this page

Topical map

Where this page sits in the registry. It's one profile among the cupcake shops in San Mateo, linked to the lists and towns around it.

Lists

  • Best cupcake shops in San Mateo: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca/san-mateo/cupcake-shop
  • Best businesses in San Mateo: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca/san-mateo

Nearby

  • /san-jose: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca/san-jose
  • /los-angeles: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca/los-angeles
  • /san-francisco: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca/san-francisco
  • /san-diego: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca/san-diego
  • /irvine: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca/irvine
  • /mountain-view: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca/mountain-view

Every list

  • Every leaderboard in California: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca

References

Show references (12)

Sources cited

  • [1] Google Business Profile, https://www.google.com/maps/place/?q=place_id:ChIJ7-Nx72Sej4ARlS3NrCI6zZI (accessed Aug 6, 2026)
  • [2] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/weddings.php (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
  • [3] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/classic-themes.php (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
  • [4] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/covid-19-updates.php (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
  • [5] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/donations@sibbyscupcakery.com (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
  • [6] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/jobs@sibbyscupcakery.com (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
  • [7] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/order.php (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
  • [8] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/signature-designs.php (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
  • [9] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/cupcakes@sibbyscupcakery.com (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
  • [10] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/custom-themes.php (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
  • [11] AI engine output: ChatGPT, read by Local AI Registry on Nov 7, 2026; ChatGPT and Perplexity, read Nov 7, 2026, https://localairegistry.com/methodology (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
  • [12] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/ (accessed Nov 6, 2026)

The code behind this page

1. HTTP response headers

The headers this page is sent with, 1 KB

2. Head tags

The head tags of this page, 1 KB

3. Structured data (JSON-LD)

The structured data on this page, 7 KB

4. Markdown copy of this page (sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca.md)

The markdown copy of this page, 11 KB

The files every page on the registry shares, and how to copy this code for your own site, are here: https://localairegistry.com/developers

References, including locals

  1. lunch near Railroad, what is good Question by early_on_railroad, Sep 14, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/what-is-around-sibbys-cupcakery-on-railroad
  2. Any membership pricing at Sibby's Cupcakery? Question by undecided_on_railroad, Sep 11, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/does-sibbys-cupcakery-take-rewards-points-or-membership-pricing
  3. what time does Sibby's Cupcakery in San Mateo actually open? Question by long_overdue_on_railroad, Sep 11, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/what-are-the-hours-of-operation-for-sibbys-cupcakery
  4. best cupcake shop in San Mateo Question by reunion_regular_east, Sep 8, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/best-cupcake-shop-in-san-mateo
  5. people keep recommending Sibby's Cupcakery, what for? Question by wedding_reader_north, Sep 4, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/what-is-sibbys-cupcakery-known-for
  6. Sibby's Cupcakery, any chance to get in this week? Question by june_sitter_west, Sep 4, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/does-sibbys-cupcakery-ever-have-last-minute-openings
  7. going rate for shops locally, any idea Question by curious_on_railroad, Sep 1, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/what-does-a-cupcake-shop-actually-cost-in-san-mateo
  8. Mondays at Sibby's Cupcakery, are they open? Question by san_mateo_owl_94401, Aug 28, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/is-sibbys-cupcakery-open-on-mondays
  9. last update from here was when? Question by railroad_otis, Aug 26, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/what-has-sibbys-cupcakery-been-posting-lately
  10. On a budget in San Mateo, is Sibby's Cupcakery the one? Question by may_shopper_west, Aug 21, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/is-there-anywhere-cheaper-than-sibbys-cupcakery-in-san-mateo-that-is
  11. parking at Sibby's Cupcakery, where does everyone put the car? Question by holiday_walker_downtown, Aug 16, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/is-there-parking-available-near-sibbys-cupcakery
  12. worth it or not, what do the regulars say Question by researching_on_railroad, Aug 10, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/what-do-people-actually-like-about-sibbys-cupcakery
  13. services here, what do people go in for? Question by no_rush_on_railroad, Aug 6, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/what-special-features-does-sibbys-cupcakery-offer
  14. Booking a first visit here, what happens? Question by summer_shopper_north, Jul 30, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/what-should-i-know-before-a-first-visit-at-sibbys-cupcakery
  15. bad experiences at Sibby's Cupcakery, anyone? Question by second_opinion_on_railroad, Jul 27, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/the-reviews-look-glowing-what-are-the-real-complaints
  16. do I need to book the shop or can I just turn up? Question by lowkey_on_railroad, Jul 22, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/does-sibbys-cupcakery-accept-reservations

You're free to copy anything on this page, as long as you keep the reference links. How to copy it or link to it

References

Change history
ConfirmedVisitor submittedAI guess
Show references (12)

This is the evidence for every fact on this page, across Locals, Services, Team, Visit, Reputation and Updates. What each mark means

  1. [1]VisitName, address, phone, hours and 2 other detailsGoogle Business Profile.Primary source · Accessed Aug 6, 2026 · https://www.google.com/maps/place/?q=place_id:ChIJ7-Nx72Sej4ARlS3NrCI6zZI
  2. [2]ServicesWeddingssibbyscupcakery.com.Primary source · Accessed Sep 18, 2026 · https://sibbyscupcakery.com/weddings.php
  3. [3]ServicesClassic themessibbyscupcakery.com.Primary source · Accessed Sep 18, 2026 · https://sibbyscupcakery.com/classic-themes.php
  4. [4]ServicesCovid 19 updatessibbyscupcakery.com.Primary source · Accessed Sep 18, 2026 · https://sibbyscupcakery.com/covid-19-updates.php
  5. [5]ServicesDonations sibbyscupcakery comsibbyscupcakery.com.Primary source · Accessed Sep 18, 2026 · https://sibbyscupcakery.com/donations@sibbyscupcakery.com
  6. [6]ServicesJobs sibbyscupcakery comsibbyscupcakery.com.Primary source · Accessed Sep 18, 2026 · https://sibbyscupcakery.com/jobs@sibbyscupcakery.com
  7. [7]ServicesOrdersibbyscupcakery.com.Primary source · Accessed Sep 18, 2026 · https://sibbyscupcakery.com/order.php
  8. [8]ServicesSignature designssibbyscupcakery.com.Primary source · Accessed Sep 18, 2026 · https://sibbyscupcakery.com/signature-designs.php
  9. [9]ServicesCupcakes sibbyscupcakery comsibbyscupcakery.com.Primary source · Accessed Sep 18, 2026 · https://sibbyscupcakery.com/cupcakes@sibbyscupcakery.com
  10. [10]ServicesCustom themessibbyscupcakery.com.Primary source · Accessed Sep 18, 2026 · https://sibbyscupcakery.com/custom-themes.php
  11. [11]ServicesClassic themed cupcakes, Custom themed cupcakes and Signature cupcake designsAI engine output: ChatGPT, read by Local AI Registry on Nov 7, 2026; ChatGPT and Perplexity, read Nov 7, 2026.AI engine output · Accessed Sep 18, 2026 · https://localairegistry.com/methodology
  12. [12]VisitFacebook, instagram and yelpsibbyscupcakery.com.Primary source · Accessed Nov 6, 2026 · https://sibbyscupcakery.com/ · Archived copy
Get directions