Local AI Registry · Cupcake shops in San Mateo, CA · Editorial
Sibby's Cupcakery, San Mateo CA: Cupcake shop
By Steve Lee, founder and CEO of Local AI Registry. Updated November 15, 2026.
Published August 6, 2026 · Updated November 15, 2026 · Machine-readable version below
In short
Sibby's Cupcakery is a cupcake shop in San Mateo, CA. Its AI Score is 63 of 100.
What each mark on this page means: https://localairegistry.com/methodology#marks
Key facts
| Fact | Value |
|---|---|
| Type | Cupcake shop |
| Address | 716 S Railroad Ave, San Mateo, CA 94401, USA |
| Hours | Closed Mon to Tue · Wed to Fri 10 AM to 5:30 PM · Sat 10 AM to 5 PM · Sun 10 AM to 2 PM |
| Phone | (415) 613-4373 |
| Rating | 4.7 across 139 reviews on Google |
| Updated | November 15, 2026 |
All the details
Every row is something the owner can add or correct.
| Group | Fact | Value | Mark | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Location info | Address | 716 S Railroad Ave, San Mateo, CA 94401, USA | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Location info | Description | 716 S Railroad Ave, San Mateo, CA 94401 | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Location info | Hours | Mon to Tue Closed · Wed to Fri 10:00 AM to 5:30 PM · Sat 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM · Sun 10:00 AM to 2:00 PM | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Location info | Mondays | Closed | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Location info | Name | Sibby's Cupcakery | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Location info | Phone | (415) 613-4373 | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Hours | Monday | Closed | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Hours | Tuesday | Closed | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Hours | Wednesday | 10:00 AM to 5:30 PM | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Hours | Thursday | 10:00 AM to 5:30 PM | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Hours | Friday | 10:00 AM to 5:30 PM | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Hours | Saturday | 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Hours | Sunday | 10:00 AM to 2:00 PM | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Services | Service | Classic themed cupcakes | AI guess | |
| Services | Service | Classic themes | From their website | Business website |
| Services | Service | Covid 19 updates | From their website | Business website |
| Services | Service | Cupcakes sibbyscupcakery com | From their website | Business website |
| Services | Service | Custom themed cupcakes | AI guess | |
| Services | Service | Custom themes | From their website | Business website |
| Services | Service | Donations sibbyscupcakery com | From their website | Business website |
| Services | Service | Jobs sibbyscupcakery com | From their website | Business website |
| Services | Service | Order | From their website | Business website |
| Services | Service | Signature cupcake designs | AI guess | |
| Services | Service | Signature designs | From their website | Business website |
| Services | Service | Weddings | From their website | Business website |
| Links | https://www.facebook.com/sibbys-cupcakery | Confirmed | Business website | |
| Links | https://www.instagram.com/sibbyscupcakery | Confirmed | Business website | |
| Links | Website | https://sibbyscupcakery.com/ | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Links | Yelp | https://www.yelp.com/biz/sibbys-cupcakery-san-mateo | Confirmed | Business website |
Services and prices
These are the 9 services Sibby's Cupcakery offers, with the price where we have one and where it came from.
| Service | Price | Price mark | Price evidence | Service mark |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Covid 19 updates | From their website | |||
| Weddings | From their website | |||
| Cupcakes sibbyscupcakery com | From their website | |||
| Custom themes | From their website | |||
| Signature designs | From their website | |||
| Jobs sibbyscupcakery com | From their website | |||
| Order | From their website | |||
| Donations sibbyscupcakery com | From their website | |||
| Classic themes | From their website |
Known for
The team
Visiting Sibby's Cupcakery
Address: 716 S Railroad Ave, San Mateo, CA 94401, USA. Phone: (415) 613-4373. Hours: Closed Mon to Tue · Wed to Fri 10 AM to 5:30 PM · Sat 10 AM to 5 PM · Sun 10 AM to 2 PM. (Confirmed, Google Business Profile.)
Parking and getting in
Nearby
| Place | Type | Distance |
|---|---|---|
| Charlie's Taqueria | Mexican restaurant | 1 min walk |
| Ramen Dojo | Ramen restaurant | 1 min walk |
| Anatolian Cafe & Market | Breakfast restaurant | 2 min walk |
| Espetus Churrascaria Brazilian Steakhouse - San Mateo | Brazilian restaurant | 2 min walk |
| Sama Coffee Shop | Coffee shop | 2 min walk |
| Ramen Parlor | Ramen restaurant | 2 min walk |
Reputation
4.7 average across 139 reviews: Google 139. (Confirmed, read August 6, 2026.)
Sibby's Cupcakery stands out for its seasonal flavors and custom orders, though customer service and ordering processes could use improvement. (AI guess, from 139 reviews.)
What people like
- Custom orders for special occasions
- Seasonal flavor options
- Moist cake with rich frosting
- Friendly and helpful staff
- Variety of gluten-free flavors
What people do not like
- Rude customer service experiences
- Complicated online ordering system
- Long waits outside for pickup
- Cupcakes sliding in transit containers
Press
Awards
Directories
Questions people ask
lunch near Railroad, what is good
Any membership pricing at Sibby's Cupcakery?
what time does Sibby's Cupcakery in San Mateo actually open?
best cupcake shop in San Mateo
people keep recommending Sibby's Cupcakery, what for?
Sibby's Cupcakery, any chance to get in this week?
going rate for shops locally, any idea
Mondays at Sibby's Cupcakery, are they open?
last update from here was when?
On a budget in San Mateo, is Sibby's Cupcakery the one?
parking at Sibby's Cupcakery, where does everyone put the car?
worth it or not, what do the regulars say
services here, what do people go in for?
Booking a first visit here, what happens?
bad experiences at Sibby's Cupcakery, anyone?
do I need to book the shop or can I just turn up?
The AI Score: 63 of 100
Fair starts at 45, good at 65. Sibby's Cupcakery scores 63.
| Signal | Weight | Score | Sibby's Cupcakery |
|---|---|---|---|
| Retrieval grounding | 26 | 75 | Good |
| Off-property attestation | 20 | 41 | Poor |
| AI visibility | 14 | 67 | Good |
| Reviews & response | 12 | 82 | Good |
| Backlink & citation authority | 8 | 57 | Fair |
| Google Business Profile | 8 | 90 | Good |
| Speed & mobile | 7 | 66 | Good |
| Content freshness & schema | 5 | 37 | Poor |
- ChatGPT: read Nov 7, 2026, and it mentioned Sibby's Cupcakery
- Perplexity: read Nov 7, 2026, and it didn't mention Sibby's Cupcakery
Full method: https://localairegistry.com/methodology
How AI decides what to say about a cupcake shop: https://localairegistry.com/methodology#how-ai-decides-local-business. What to check before you choose one: https://localairegistry.com/methodology#how-to-choose-local-business
Entity map
| Entity | Type | ID on this page | Same as | Relationship to Sibby's Cupcakery |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sibby's Cupcakery | LocalBusiness | #business | https://sibbyscupcakery.com/ | Subject of this page |
| San Mateo, California | City | #city | City Sibby's Cupcakery is in | |
| Local AI Registry | Organization | #publisher | https://localairegistry.com | Publisher of this page |
| Steve Lee | Person | #author | https://localairegistry.com/team/steve-lee | Author of this page |
Topical map
Where this page sits in the registry. It's one profile among the cupcake shops in San Mateo, linked to the lists and towns around it.
Lists
- Best cupcake shops in San Mateo: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca/san-mateo/cupcake-shop
- Best businesses in San Mateo: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca/san-mateo
Nearby
- /san-jose: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca/san-jose
- /los-angeles: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca/los-angeles
- /san-francisco: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca/san-francisco
- /san-diego: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca/san-diego
- /irvine: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca/irvine
- /mountain-view: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca/mountain-view
Every list
- Every leaderboard in California: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/ca
References
Show references (12)
Sources cited
- [1] Google Business Profile, https://www.google.com/maps/place/?q=place_id:ChIJ7-Nx72Sej4ARlS3NrCI6zZI (accessed Aug 6, 2026)
- [2] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/weddings.php (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
- [3] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/classic-themes.php (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
- [4] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/covid-19-updates.php (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
- [5] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/donations@sibbyscupcakery.com (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
- [6] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/jobs@sibbyscupcakery.com (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
- [7] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/order.php (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
- [8] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/signature-designs.php (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
- [9] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/cupcakes@sibbyscupcakery.com (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
- [10] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/custom-themes.php (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
- [11] AI engine output: ChatGPT, read by Local AI Registry on Nov 7, 2026; ChatGPT and Perplexity, read Nov 7, 2026, https://localairegistry.com/methodology (accessed Sep 18, 2026)
- [12] sibbyscupcakery.com, https://sibbyscupcakery.com/ (accessed Nov 6, 2026)
The code behind this page
1. HTTP response headers
The headers this page is sent with, 1 KB
2. Head tags
The head tags of this page, 1 KB
3. Structured data (JSON-LD)
The structured data on this page, 7 KB
4. Markdown copy of this page (sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca.md)
The markdown copy of this page, 11 KB
The files every page on the registry shares, and how to copy this code for your own site, are here: https://localairegistry.com/developers
References, including locals
- lunch near Railroad, what is good Question by early_on_railroad, Sep 14, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/what-is-around-sibbys-cupcakery-on-railroad
- Any membership pricing at Sibby's Cupcakery? Question by undecided_on_railroad, Sep 11, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/does-sibbys-cupcakery-take-rewards-points-or-membership-pricing
- what time does Sibby's Cupcakery in San Mateo actually open? Question by long_overdue_on_railroad, Sep 11, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/what-are-the-hours-of-operation-for-sibbys-cupcakery
- best cupcake shop in San Mateo Question by reunion_regular_east, Sep 8, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/best-cupcake-shop-in-san-mateo
- people keep recommending Sibby's Cupcakery, what for? Question by wedding_reader_north, Sep 4, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/what-is-sibbys-cupcakery-known-for
- Sibby's Cupcakery, any chance to get in this week? Question by june_sitter_west, Sep 4, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/does-sibbys-cupcakery-ever-have-last-minute-openings
- going rate for shops locally, any idea Question by curious_on_railroad, Sep 1, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/what-does-a-cupcake-shop-actually-cost-in-san-mateo
- Mondays at Sibby's Cupcakery, are they open? Question by san_mateo_owl_94401, Aug 28, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/is-sibbys-cupcakery-open-on-mondays
- last update from here was when? Question by railroad_otis, Aug 26, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/what-has-sibbys-cupcakery-been-posting-lately
- On a budget in San Mateo, is Sibby's Cupcakery the one? Question by may_shopper_west, Aug 21, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/is-there-anywhere-cheaper-than-sibbys-cupcakery-in-san-mateo-that-is
- parking at Sibby's Cupcakery, where does everyone put the car? Question by holiday_walker_downtown, Aug 16, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/is-there-parking-available-near-sibbys-cupcakery
- worth it or not, what do the regulars say Question by researching_on_railroad, Aug 10, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/what-do-people-actually-like-about-sibbys-cupcakery
- services here, what do people go in for? Question by no_rush_on_railroad, Aug 6, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/what-special-features-does-sibbys-cupcakery-offer
- Booking a first visit here, what happens? Question by summer_shopper_north, Jul 30, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/what-should-i-know-before-a-first-visit-at-sibbys-cupcakery
- bad experiences at Sibby's Cupcakery, anyone? Question by second_opinion_on_railroad, Jul 27, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/the-reviews-look-glowing-what-are-the-real-complaints
- do I need to book the shop or can I just turn up? Question by lowkey_on_railroad, Jul 22, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/ca/san-mateo/sibby-s-cupcakery-san-mateo-ca/q/does-sibbys-cupcakery-accept-reservations
You're free to copy anything on this page, as long as you keep the reference links. How to copy it or link to it










