Local AI Registry · Convenience stores in Mayfield Heights, OH · Editorial
Sheetz, Mayfield Heights OH: Convenience store, Reviews
By Steve Lee, founder and CEO of Local AI Registry. Updated September 9, 2026.
Published September 9, 2026 · Updated September 9, 2026 · Machine-readable version below
In short
Sheetz is a convenience store in Mayfield Heights, OH. Its AI Score is 30 of 100.
What each mark on this page means: https://localairegistry.com/methodology#marks
Key facts
| Fact | Value |
|---|---|
| Type | Convenience store |
| Address | 5900 Mayfield Rd, Mayfield Heights, OH 44124, USA |
| Hours | Mon to Sun Open 24 hours |
| Phone | (216) 803-9708 |
| Rating | 3.3 across 136 reviews on Google |
| Quietest time | Sunday |
| Updated | September 9, 2026 |
All the details
Every row is something the owner can add or correct.
| Group | Fact | Value | Mark | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Location info | Address | 5900 Mayfield Rd, Mayfield Heights, OH 44124, USA | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Location info | Description | Chain offering fuel & familiar convenience goods, including packaged snacks, drinks & takeaway fare. | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Location info | Hours | Mon to Sun Open 24 hours | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Location info | Mondays | Open 24 hours | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Location info | Name | Sheetz | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Location info | Phone | (216) 803-9708 | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Hours | Monday | Open 24 hours | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Hours | Tuesday | Open 24 hours | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Hours | Wednesday | Open 24 hours | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Hours | Thursday | Open 24 hours | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Hours | Friday | Open 24 hours | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Hours | Saturday | Open 24 hours | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Hours | Sunday | Open 24 hours | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
| Services | Service | Drinks | AI guess | |
| Services | Service | Fuel station | AI guess | |
| Services | Service | Packaged snacks | AI guess | |
| Services | Service | Takeaway food | AI guess | |
| Links | Website | https://orders.sheetz.com/findASheetz/store/743 | Confirmed | Google Business Profile |
Services and prices
Known for
The team
Visiting Sheetz
Address: 5900 Mayfield Rd, Mayfield Heights, OH 44124, USA. Phone: (216) 803-9708. Hours: Mon to Sun Open 24 hours. (Confirmed, Google Business Profile.)
Location info from Google Business Profile
From Google Business Profile: "Chain offering fuel & familiar convenience goods, including packaged snacks, drinks & takeaway fare."
When to go
Quietest day: Sunday. Busiest day: Friday. From the popular times on its Google listing.
Parking and getting in
Nearby
| Place | Type | Distance |
|---|---|---|
| Mayfield Rd & Mayfield Ridge Rd | Bus stop | 1 min walk |
| Moe's Southwest Grill | Mexican restaurant | 1 min walk |
| Mayfield Rd & Mayfield Ridge Rd | Transit station | 1 min walk |
| Raising Cane's Chicken Fingers | Fast food restaurant | 1 min walk |
| Mayfield Rd & Mayfield Ridge Rd | Bus station | 2 min walk |
| Pulp Juice and Smoothie Bar | Juice shop | 2 min walk |
Reputation
3.3 average across 136 reviews: Google 136. (Confirmed, read September 9, 2026.)
Despite its 24/7 availability and varied menu, this Sheetz struggles with service quality and safety issues, making it a less appealing choice for customers. (AI guess, from 136 reviews.)
What people like
- Tacos and fries
- Diverse food menu
- Open 24/7
What people do not like
- Long waits for food preparation
- Store often messy
- Unprofessional staff behavior
- Safety concerns due to loitering
Press
Awards
Directories
Questions people ask
membership, worth it or not
where exactly is Sheetz?
is there a day here that is not slammed
opening hours at Sheetz in Mayfield Heights, what are they these days?
walking in for a first visit, what happens
budget options in Mayfield Heights, what is decent
anywhere on Mayfield to sit while I wait
What do shoppers most often mention buying here?
best convenience store in Mayfield Heights
are prices in Mayfield Heights higher than everywhere else
last update from here was when?
does the shop ever have cancellations
Why do people rate Sheetz?
Downsides nobody puts in a five star review?
The AI Score: 30 of 100
Convenience stores on the registry run 14 to 49. Fair starts at 45, good at 65. Sheetz scores 30.
| Signal | Weight | Score | Sheetz |
|---|---|---|---|
| Retrieval grounding | 26 | 0 | Poor |
| Off-property attestation | 20 | 40 | Poor |
| AI visibility | 14 | 50 | Fair |
| Reviews & response | 12 | 68 | Good |
| Backlink & citation authority | 8 | 60 | Fair |
| Google Business Profile | 8 | 90 | Good |
| Speed & mobile | 7 | 21 | Poor |
| Content freshness & schema | 5 | 32 | Poor |
- ChatGPT: read Nov 15, 2026, and it mentioned Sheetz
- Perplexity: read Nov 15, 2026, and it didn't mention Sheetz
Full method: https://localairegistry.com/methodology
How AI decides what to say about a convenience store: https://localairegistry.com/methodology#how-ai-decides-local-business. What to check before you choose one: https://localairegistry.com/methodology#how-to-choose-local-business
Entity map
| Entity | Type | ID on this page | Same as | Relationship to Sheetz |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sheetz | LocalBusiness | #business | https://orders.sheetz.com/findASheetz/store/743 | Subject of this page |
| Mayfield Heights, Ohio | City | #city | City Sheetz is in | |
| Local AI Registry | Organization | #publisher | https://localairegistry.com | Publisher of this page |
| Steve Lee | Person | #author | https://localairegistry.com/team/steve-lee | Author of this page |
Topical map
Where this page sits in the registry. It's one profile among the convenience stores in Mayfield Heights, linked to the lists and towns around it.
Lists
- Best convenience stores in Mayfield Heights: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh/mayfield-heights/convenience-store
- Best businesses in Mayfield Heights: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh/mayfield-heights
Nearby
- /columbus: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh/columbus
- /cleveland: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh/cleveland
- /toledo: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh/toledo
- /gahanna: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh/gahanna
- /grove-city: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh/grove-city
- /dublin: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh/dublin
Every list
- Every leaderboard in Ohio: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh
References
Show references (2)
Sources cited
The code behind this page
1. HTTP response headers
The headers this page is sent with, 1 KB
2. Head tags
The head tags of this page, 1 KB
3. Structured data (JSON-LD)
The structured data on this page, 8 KB
4. Markdown copy of this page (sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh.md)
The markdown copy of this page, 8 KB
The files every page on the registry shares, and how to copy this code for your own site, are here: https://localairegistry.com/developers
References, including locals
- membership, worth it or not Question by reading_reviews_on_mayfield, Sep 14, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/does-sheetz-take-rewards-points-or-membership-pricing
- where exactly is Sheetz? Question by hopeful_in_mh, Sep 12, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/where-is-sheetz-located
- is there a day here that is not slammed Question by reunion_parent_downtown, Sep 10, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/what-is-the-quietest-day-to-book-at-sheetz
- opening hours at Sheetz in Mayfield Heights, what are they these days? Question by careful_in_mh, Sep 9, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/what-are-the-hours-of-operation-for-sheetz
- walking in for a first visit, what happens Question by spontaneous_on_mayfield, Sep 7, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/what-should-i-know-before-a-first-visit-at-sheetz
- budget options in Mayfield Heights, what is decent Question by circling_on_mayfield_44124, Sep 4, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/is-there-anywhere-cheaper-than-sheetz-in-mayfield-heights-that-is-still
- anywhere on Mayfield to sit while I wait Question by new_here_on_mayfield, Sep 3, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/what-is-around-sheetz-on-mayfield
- What do shoppers most often mention buying here? Question by mayfield_wilder, Aug 27, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/what-do-shoppers-most-often-mention-buying-at-sheetz
- best convenience store in Mayfield Heights Question by winter_parent_south, Aug 23, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/best-convenience-store-in-mayfield-heights
- are prices in Mayfield Heights higher than everywhere else Question by autumn_reader_east, Aug 20, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/what-does-a-convenience-store-actually-cost-in-mayfield-heights
- last update from here was when? Question by june_runner_uptown, Aug 13, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/what-has-sheetz-been-posting-lately
- does the shop ever have cancellations Question by researching_on_mayfield, Aug 7, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/does-sheetz-ever-have-last-minute-openings
- Why do people rate Sheetz? Question by new_here_in_mh, Aug 5, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/what-do-people-actually-like-about-sheetz
- Downsides nobody puts in a five star review? Question by heights_sage, Jul 31, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/the-reviews-look-glowing-what-are-the-real-complaints
You're free to copy anything on this page, as long as you keep the reference links. How to copy it or link to it




