Sheetz

Unclaimed
Sheetz photo 1[Photo 1]
Sheetz photo 2[Photo 2]
Sheetz photo 3[Photo 3]

Convenience store in Mayfield Heights, OH

3.3 · 136 reviewsOpen until 11:59

Chain offering fuel & familiar convenience goods, including packaged snacks, drinks & takeaway fare.

Eligible to offer 20% cashback to customers who shop here.OrbitBack

AI ScoreAI names Sheetz more than most convenience storesScored from 8 signals across search and AI.

How the score works

Owned by Sheetz

Unclaimed · Never replied

Is this you? Claim it

ConfirmedVisitor submittedAI guess

Updated Sep 9, 2026Last activity 2 months ago, a question from reading_reviews_on_mayfield.

No questions yet. Ask the first one.

Services

What Sheetz offers, what it costs, and what people come for.

Sheetz photo 1No code detected[Photo 1]
Sheetz photo 2No code detected[Photo 2]
Sheetz photo 3No code detected[Photo 3]
Sheetz photo 4No code detected[Photo 4]

Team

Who you'll see, and whether their licenses check out.
Add your team so AI can name who works here
TodayOpen 24 hours
MondaysOpen 24 hours

Busy times

Usually not too busy now. Busiest Wed and Fri, noon to 8.

Reputation

What reviews, press and directories say about Sheetz.

Reviews

3.3from 136 reviews on Google

Despite its 24/7 availability and varied menu, this Sheetz struggles with service quality and safety issues, making it a less appealing choice for customers. Customers report a mix of late-night convenience and frustration at Sheetz in Mayfield Heights. While some appreciate the diverse food options like tacos and fries, many express dissatisfaction with service speed, cleanliness, and safety concerns, particularly at night.

  • 564%
  • 40%
  • 34%
  • 20%
  • 132%
Would go back64%64% of reviews give the visit 4 or 5 stars.Positive 64%, 4 or 5 stars · Neutral 4%, 3 stars · Negative 32%, 1 or 2 stars
The good
  • Tacos and fries
  • Diverse food menu
  • Open 24/7
The bad
  • Long waits for food preparation
  • Store often messy
  • Unprofessional staff behavior
  • Safety concerns due to loitering

Press and awards

Add a press story so AI can say who's written about you

Directories

Get listed in directories so AI can tell you're real

How AI sees Sheetz

30out of 100

What the score is made of

Signal and how much it countsSheetz

  • Retrieval grounding 26%0
  • Off-property attestation 20%40
  • AI visibility 14%50
  • Reviews & response 12%68
  • Backlink & citation authority 8%60
  • Google Business Profile 8%90
  • Speed & mobile 7%21
  • Content freshness & schema 5%32
How the score works
Sheetz’s full AI report

See exactly what AI says about you, and how to get picked

SheetzSpeed & mobileGoogle Business ProfileContent freshness & schemaBacklink & citation authorityRetrieval groundingReviews & responseOff-property attestationAI visibility

Sheetz, as AI sees it. Blue signals help Sheetz, and red ones hold it back.

  • The questions people ask ChatGPT and Perplexity about convenience stores in Mayfield Heights, and who they name instead of you
  • What AI gets wrong about you, next to what’s true
  • What to change first so AI names you
Claim free to get the report

Claiming your page is free.

What AI reads

The page ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google read about Sheetz. How AI reads this page

Local AI Registry · Convenience stores in Mayfield Heights, OH · Editorial

Sheetz, Mayfield Heights OH: Convenience store, Reviews

Steve Lee

By Steve Lee, founder and CEO of Local AI Registry. Updated September 9, 2026.

Published September 9, 2026 · Updated September 9, 2026 · Machine-readable version below

In short

Sheetz is a convenience store in Mayfield Heights, OH. Its AI Score is 30 of 100.

What each mark on this page means: https://localairegistry.com/methodology#marks

Key facts

FactValue
TypeConvenience store
Address5900 Mayfield Rd, Mayfield Heights, OH 44124, USA
HoursMon to Sun Open 24 hours
Phone(216) 803-9708
Rating3.3 across 136 reviews on Google
Quietest timeSunday
UpdatedSeptember 9, 2026

All the details

Every row is something the owner can add or correct.

GroupFactValueMarkEvidence
Location infoAddress5900 Mayfield Rd, Mayfield Heights, OH 44124, USAConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
Location infoDescriptionChain offering fuel & familiar convenience goods, including packaged snacks, drinks & takeaway fare.ConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
Location infoHoursMon to Sun Open 24 hoursConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
Location infoMondaysOpen 24 hoursConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
Location infoNameSheetzConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
Location infoPhone(216) 803-9708ConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
HoursMondayOpen 24 hoursConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
HoursTuesdayOpen 24 hoursConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
HoursWednesdayOpen 24 hoursConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
HoursThursdayOpen 24 hoursConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
HoursFridayOpen 24 hoursConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
HoursSaturdayOpen 24 hoursConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
HoursSundayOpen 24 hoursConfirmedGoogle Business Profile
ServicesServiceDrinksAI guess
ServicesServiceFuel stationAI guess
ServicesServicePackaged snacksAI guess
ServicesServiceTakeaway foodAI guess
LinksWebsitehttps://orders.sheetz.com/findASheetz/store/743ConfirmedGoogle Business Profile

Services and prices

Known for

The team

Visiting Sheetz

Address: 5900 Mayfield Rd, Mayfield Heights, OH 44124, USA. Phone: (216) 803-9708. Hours: Mon to Sun Open 24 hours. (Confirmed, Google Business Profile.)

Location info from Google Business Profile

From Google Business Profile: "Chain offering fuel & familiar convenience goods, including packaged snacks, drinks & takeaway fare."

When to go

Quietest day: Sunday. Busiest day: Friday. From the popular times on its Google listing.

Parking and getting in

Nearby

PlaceTypeDistance
Mayfield Rd & Mayfield Ridge RdBus stop1 min walk
Moe's Southwest GrillMexican restaurant1 min walk
Mayfield Rd & Mayfield Ridge RdTransit station1 min walk
Raising Cane's Chicken FingersFast food restaurant1 min walk
Mayfield Rd & Mayfield Ridge RdBus station2 min walk
Pulp Juice and Smoothie BarJuice shop2 min walk

Reputation

3.3 average across 136 reviews: Google 136. (Confirmed, read September 9, 2026.)

Despite its 24/7 availability and varied menu, this Sheetz struggles with service quality and safety issues, making it a less appealing choice for customers. (AI guess, from 136 reviews.)

What people like

  • Tacos and fries
  • Diverse food menu
  • Open 24/7

What people do not like

  • Long waits for food preparation
  • Store often messy
  • Unprofessional staff behavior
  • Safety concerns due to loitering

Press

Awards

Directories

Questions people ask

membership, worth it or not

where exactly is Sheetz?

is there a day here that is not slammed

opening hours at Sheetz in Mayfield Heights, what are they these days?

walking in for a first visit, what happens

budget options in Mayfield Heights, what is decent

anywhere on Mayfield to sit while I wait

What do shoppers most often mention buying here?

best convenience store in Mayfield Heights

are prices in Mayfield Heights higher than everywhere else

last update from here was when?

does the shop ever have cancellations

Why do people rate Sheetz?

Downsides nobody puts in a five star review?

The AI Score: 30 of 100

Convenience stores on the registry run 14 to 49. Fair starts at 45, good at 65. Sheetz scores 30.

SignalWeightScoreSheetz
Retrieval grounding260Poor
Off-property attestation2040Poor
AI visibility1450Fair
Reviews & response1268Good
Backlink & citation authority860Fair
Google Business Profile890Good
Speed & mobile721Poor
Content freshness & schema532Poor
  • ChatGPT: read Nov 15, 2026, and it mentioned Sheetz
  • Perplexity: read Nov 15, 2026, and it didn't mention Sheetz

Full method: https://localairegistry.com/methodology

How AI decides what to say about a convenience store: https://localairegistry.com/methodology#how-ai-decides-local-business. What to check before you choose one: https://localairegistry.com/methodology#how-to-choose-local-business

Entity map

EntityTypeID on this pageSame asRelationship to Sheetz
SheetzLocalBusiness#businesshttps://orders.sheetz.com/findASheetz/store/743Subject of this page
Mayfield Heights, OhioCity#cityCity Sheetz is in
Local AI RegistryOrganization#publisherhttps://localairegistry.comPublisher of this page
Steve LeePerson#authorhttps://localairegistry.com/team/steve-leeAuthor of this page

Topical map

Where this page sits in the registry. It's one profile among the convenience stores in Mayfield Heights, linked to the lists and towns around it.

Lists

  • Best convenience stores in Mayfield Heights: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh/mayfield-heights/convenience-store
  • Best businesses in Mayfield Heights: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh/mayfield-heights

Nearby

  • /columbus: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh/columbus
  • /cleveland: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh/cleveland
  • /toledo: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh/toledo
  • /gahanna: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh/gahanna
  • /grove-city: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh/grove-city
  • /dublin: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh/dublin

Every list

  • Every leaderboard in Ohio: https://localairegistry.com/leaderboards/oh

References

Show references (2)

Sources cited

  • [1] Google Business Profile, https://www.google.com/maps/place/?q=place_id:ChIJ2XDLTuQDMYgR-VYiczX4AoI (accessed Sep 9, 2026)
  • [2] AI engine output: ChatGPT, read by Local AI Registry on Nov 15, 2026; Perplexity, read Nov 15, 2026, https://localairegistry.com/methodology (accessed Sep 19, 2026)

The code behind this page

1. HTTP response headers

The headers this page is sent with, 1 KB

2. Head tags

The head tags of this page, 1 KB

3. Structured data (JSON-LD)

The structured data on this page, 8 KB

4. Markdown copy of this page (sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh.md)

The markdown copy of this page, 8 KB

The files every page on the registry shares, and how to copy this code for your own site, are here: https://localairegistry.com/developers

References, including locals

  1. membership, worth it or not Question by reading_reviews_on_mayfield, Sep 14, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/does-sheetz-take-rewards-points-or-membership-pricing
  2. where exactly is Sheetz? Question by hopeful_in_mh, Sep 12, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/where-is-sheetz-located
  3. is there a day here that is not slammed Question by reunion_parent_downtown, Sep 10, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/what-is-the-quietest-day-to-book-at-sheetz
  4. opening hours at Sheetz in Mayfield Heights, what are they these days? Question by careful_in_mh, Sep 9, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/what-are-the-hours-of-operation-for-sheetz
  5. walking in for a first visit, what happens Question by spontaneous_on_mayfield, Sep 7, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/what-should-i-know-before-a-first-visit-at-sheetz
  6. budget options in Mayfield Heights, what is decent Question by circling_on_mayfield_44124, Sep 4, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/is-there-anywhere-cheaper-than-sheetz-in-mayfield-heights-that-is-still
  7. anywhere on Mayfield to sit while I wait Question by new_here_on_mayfield, Sep 3, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/what-is-around-sheetz-on-mayfield
  8. What do shoppers most often mention buying here? Question by mayfield_wilder, Aug 27, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/what-do-shoppers-most-often-mention-buying-at-sheetz
  9. best convenience store in Mayfield Heights Question by winter_parent_south, Aug 23, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/best-convenience-store-in-mayfield-heights
  10. are prices in Mayfield Heights higher than everywhere else Question by autumn_reader_east, Aug 20, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/what-does-a-convenience-store-actually-cost-in-mayfield-heights
  11. last update from here was when? Question by june_runner_uptown, Aug 13, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/what-has-sheetz-been-posting-lately
  12. does the shop ever have cancellations Question by researching_on_mayfield, Aug 7, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/does-sheetz-ever-have-last-minute-openings
  13. Why do people rate Sheetz? Question by new_here_in_mh, Aug 5, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/what-do-people-actually-like-about-sheetz
  14. Downsides nobody puts in a five star review? Question by heights_sage, Jul 31, 2026. localairegistry.com/biz/oh/mayfield-heights/sheetz-mayfield-heights-oh/q/the-reviews-look-glowing-what-are-the-real-complaints

You're free to copy anything on this page, as long as you keep the reference links. How to copy it or link to it

References

Change history
ConfirmedVisitor submittedAI guess
Show references (2)

This is the evidence for every fact on this page, across Locals, Services, Team, Visit, Reputation and Updates. What each mark means

  1. [1]VisitName, address, phone, hours and 2 other detailsGoogle Business Profile.Primary source · Accessed Sep 9, 2026 · https://www.google.com/maps/place/?q=place_id:ChIJ2XDLTuQDMYgR-VYiczX4AoI
  2. [2]Services4 servicesAI engine output: ChatGPT, read by Local AI Registry on Nov 15, 2026; Perplexity, read Nov 15, 2026.AI engine output · Accessed Sep 19, 2026 · https://localairegistry.com/methodology
Get directions